The Walther put this fine ammo into ten-shot groups of 2.6 inches and 2.8 inches respectively. They are also viable for training new shooters, or for keeping one’s eye in on rapid-fire shooting of multiple targets, at very low cost. The slide release is located in the expected position just above and behind the trigger at the top of the frame. We thought that was entirely adequate. Price was very close, within $10 or so. With that in mind, we decided to place them head to head and let you be the judge. Compare the dimensions and specs of Walther P22 Q and Walther P99 AS Weight is a feathery 16 oz., and it is nominally wider than the Ruger at 1 1/10 inches wide. I didn't have any serious issues with the Walther, but it was picky on ammo. A laser sight there might make some sense for those with compromised vision. By far it was easier to use a finger of the weak hand to press the button. They can provide fun on the trail too, but personally we’d prefer a gun with more accuracy if small-game hunting were on the schedule. Getting the new sight in was tricky. The top of its anodized slide was smooth and semi-gloss, instead of the Walther’s dead-flat black with longitudinal serrations. As with the Walther, the inside of the gun looked as good as the outside. The Ruger may be carried with the hammer down and the safety off, but thanks to the configuration of the safety it is highly likely and indeed easy to inadvertently re-engage the safety when acquiring the firing grip on the draw. The Walther on the other hand features their now-standard eccentric pattern molded into the frame itself. These guns are not tack drivers. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SR22 and Glock G44 How to Survive an Avalanche | Emergency Preparedness. We found both guns had distinct preferences for one or another type of ammo. The single action pull is relatively crisp and clean after a fairly significant amount of take up, a nice surprise considering most guns in this category and action have atrocious DA pulls. That’s where Ruger has an advantage, which we’ll look at in a moment. Next is the ambidextrous magazine release, which is a latch device at the bottom rear of the trigger guard that you press downward to release the magazine. Mind you, the kids are completely comfortable with the idea of clearing a jammed handgun during a high stress shooting setup. WAP22003, $301, an “Our Pick.” The test team said, “We liked this little .22 pistol immensely. While one of us was in Alaska running a trap line, the handgun was kept warm in a shoulder holster. The Walther did not reliably cycle the Federal Gold Medal Match, and had one failure to feed with the Eley Ten-X. This new and popular .22 is often compared to its closest rival, the Walther P22. But that veers off our current topic, which is pitting the two similar 22 autoloading pistols head to head. Preference for the magazine releases will likely come down to users alone, and nothing else. Hey Everyone! Another control is the slide lock, which holds the slide rearward after the last shot. The only possible explanation for not finding the .22 pistol you need is that you just did not look hard enough. The Ruger, with the same test setup, gave groups of 1.7 inches and 2.3 inches The Ruger also failed to feed both types of match ammo, which we expected. Move it down to the safe position and the hammer moves back a touch if it’s down, but doesn’t drop if it’s cocked. I owned a first gen p22 and had horrible feed issues and overall felt pretty disappointed with the quality of the gun. re: Ruger SR22 vs S&W MP22 vs Walther P22 Posted by Sea Hoss on 10/6/16 at 2:16 pm to SpeckledTiger I haven't had any feed issues or FTE issues on my SR22. Overview; Discussion (5) With any number of modern rimfire pistols out there, you know Ruger has an entry in the race-- the SR22. Some 22 LR ammo with slower-burning powder works extremely well in rifles, but not so well in short-barrel pistols. That’s the kind of accuracy we hoped for with these 22s but never got. Thread starter Muzzleloaderbill; Start date Feb 5, 2012; Muzzleloaderbill New Member. Both are quality handguns. Posted by 1 year ago. Free shipping and returns on One may compare, contrast and analyze any two guns, or any number of guns that have any set of features against each other in quest of reaching a conclusion. However, both guns refused to reliably function with Federal’s Classic High Velocity ammo, and with our final match-ammo test. It stacked badly in DA mode, breaking at 9.8 pounds, and was creepy in SA mode. The windage was slick and handy, we found, and adjusted with relative ease.… We think anyone in need of a fine little .22 pistol that works every time and doesn’t bust the bank need look no farther than the short-barrel P22. This upcoming weekend, the wife and I are finally making our move and obtaining our blue cards so that we may begin our journey into the world of guns. Both Ruger mags had flat bottoms installed, but two finger-extension magazine bottoms came with the gun. In short, the grip traction of the Walther was superior. After owning the first gen P22 CA I would definitely like the Ruger SR22 for a .22LR handgun. The Walther’s double action pull, while heavy, is smooth and a glitch-free with only some noticeable stacking near the very end of the trigger’s travel. We acquired a new Ruger and borrowed a locally owned, new-condition P22 for this test. In all cases, the slide was not driven back far enough to pick up the next round. And hope I'm a section of assisting you to get a much better product. We suspect that reader either had dirt fouling the latch or a faulty latch on his Walther. Ruger’s mechanical design is a totally different approach to essentially the same external package. We don’t recommend that method. Test your ammo, find what works best and gives best accuracy, and you’ll be a happy camper. Hey guys i'm thinking about purchasing a .22 for target practice and i'm caught between these two models. Thread starter track_warrior; Start date Jan 19, 2012; Jan 19, 2012 #1 T. track_warrior New Member. Then with the recoil spring and rod in place in the frame, we fit the forward part of the recoil spring around the slave rod, inserted the barrel in its hole, and the gun went together easily. There were three white dots. The P22 and looking at the SR22 (never held one) are/seem a bit too small. Ruger SR22 Vs Walther P22 I searched and found a few mentions but wanted an update if possible. We did not like the DA trigger at all. Took my SR22 to the range with a 525 round box ammo. Capacity is again 10+1. Each held ten rounds. Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by WVGunman, Apr 7, 2018. Inserting the magazine activated the trigger-return spring. Both guns have cumbersome safeties. SR22 will eat anything. 9 0 0. The current grip, which we left on there, had small raised rubber ribs that added a measure of traction. Whereas, the M&P runs just a bit under a full size pistol. The Ruger magazines accept a flat floorplate or a pinky extension that is significantly more generous and combined with its lack of finger grooves on the frame means that those with large hands are more likely to settle into this gun comfortably. With that in mind, we decided to place them head to head and let you be the judge. Next Last. Compare the dimensions and specs of Walther P22 Q and Walther P99 AS Like its competitor, the P22Q is a straight blowback DA/SA .22LR semi-auto pistol with a polymer frame and fixed barrel contained by an aluminum slide. If the trigger had been clean and a pound or more lighter, we would have liked the gun better. Although the Federal ammo got good velocity, its recoil impulse didn’t cycle either gun reliably. Besides, the three front-sight inserts, there was also a flat insert for the back of the grip, and we chose to change it out. There’s the trigger, with a useable DA and pleasant SA pull. Accuracy was so poor we did not record it. In a February 2006 test of four handguns, our Idaho staff called the Walther P22 22 LR No. Ruger SR 22 will feed any crap you want to cycle through it. No one makes that gun today, so far as we know. Between two guns that are just as durable and reliable the one that is easier to shoot well is the one I will always choose. Unless otherwise noted, these reviews carry the guns’ prices at the time of the original review. I’m not a person that bases my purchases off how easy or difficult any gun is to disassemble, but it is noteworthy in this review only because other people talk about it so much, and I know I will get comments about it if I did not mention it. Really only liked to cycle mini mags or any high velocity rounds. A rail for mounting of lights and lasers is also beneath the barrel on the dust cover. I bought a Ruger SR22 and decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool 22 autoloaders. Both the Ruger SR22 and the Walther P22Q are fine rimfire pistols that are suitable for a variety of tasks, from informal target shooting and plinking to the honing of fundamentals and even self-defense. It may be possible to do so without that tool, but we could not do it. Overall, both guns ran well, and would certainly meet my definition for reliable even in a defensive context so long as you stoke them with quality ammunition that you had previously tested for certain function. The safety blocks the hammer from striking the firing pin, and also locks the firing pin so the gun can’t discharge. Archived. Neither. Depressing either lever with the thumb or the trigger finger will release the magazine briskly. Barrel length is just a smidge under 3 ½ inches, and the gun has an overall length of 6 ½ inches with an overall height from keel to top of 4 ½ inches. You can lower the hammer by grasping it firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides, and pressing the trigger. It's certainly not a gun that you'll be able to shoot 1" groupings with (like the Buckmark) but is is a nice little pinker. The frame is dead black, just like that on the Walther, but the aluminum slide is more of a semi-gloss. However, for fun like busting tin cans, these guns are great. The disassembly latch is a wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines of the trigger guard. It is grippy in most conditions can afford a more secure purchase for all shooters. Our Team Said: We ended up being not so fond of the Ruger. Anyone out there have the M&P 22? Both the Ruger SR22 and the Walther P22Q are fine rimfire pistols that are suitable for a variety of tasks, from informal target shooting and plinking to the honing of fundamentals and even self-defense. In those firearms,... Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. Shop for Ruger Sr22 Vs Lcp 380 And Walther P22 22lr Pistol Vs Ruger Sr22 Ads Immediately . Plainly stated, both guns are pretty simple to disassemble, needing only their respective disassembly latches pulled or flipped down and then the slides are retracted all the way to the rear before the back end of the slide is lifted up off of the rails and then returned forward off of the barrel and frame. SR22P vs P22 - brief review - WaltherForums After looking at the exploded diagram of each (I have an SR22) I can only say that those who say Ruger copied the P22 haven't looked closely at either. We don’t know how to accurize them, or if that’s possible. That might be enough reason for a potential buyer to avoid them. Lastly, I would be remiss if I did not mention disassembly. I already own a GSG ATI22 MP5 clone … However, these grip “bumps” were not on the front of the front strap, where much of the grip pressure is placed if you know how to shoot a handgun. We got into a super-secure, seated, laid-back position and used our Merit aperture sight on our shooting glasses. The trick is to simply push the recoil spring guide rod all the way through its front aperture with the spring in place, and then hold it there with your supporting hand while guiding a slide back over the barrel and on to the frame before releasing it. The aggressive, eccentric texturing of the Walther is a welcome addition even on a gun this small with so little recoil. Walther makes it easy to install a silencer-threaded barrel where those are legal. From a purely practical standpoint they differ very little in operation or disassembly and you might fairly say that the Ruger cribbed quite a few notes from the Walther, but it is not a complete copy. It seems cheaply made and just doesn't have the features that the Ruger does. Joined: Dec 24, 2002 Messages: … We tried a final test on both guns. So long as the gun is reliable, delivers sufficient accuracy and enables the shooter to produce that accuracy with relative ease, a gun gets a pass from me. 1 of 3 Go to page. This website contains many older reviews. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Jack19 Member. The controls are simple and straightforward. Maybe, depending on your use for the gun. One more control on the P22 is the takedown latch near the front of the trigger guard, which requires you to first clear the gun, then press downward on this saddle-like latch until it drops out of the way. Walther P22 vs. Browning Buckmark vs. Ruger 22/45. NES Member. (Ruger warned against match ammo in the gun’s instruction manual.) We wish Ruger had tried to copy the original PPK 22 instead of Walthers P22. The overall look of the Ruger was attractive. NES Member. The gun is covered with serrations, angled metal and plastic, notches, grooves, and on the grip, pebble-graining. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SR22 and Walther P22 Q What would have impressed us mightily is if Ruger (or Walther) had attempted to copy the original Walther PPK for the 22LR, and brought it off nicely at a good sale price. Took it to the range the next day. I haven't owned a S&W 22, but HAVE owned a Walther P22 and currently own a SR22. From intricately crafted Olympic-grade free pistols that can produce hair-splitting accuracy to ruggedized, optic ready fullsize handguns that closely replicate their service caliber counterparts. The average improvement in group sizes obtainable with the Ruger, fired from a heavily supported benchrest position, were anywhere from 25 to 33% better than equivalent groups fired in the Walther. I Trouble shoot the problem and find the solution. Let’s take a look feature by feature: Walther also has a version with a longer barrel, and one with an integral laser sight for $479. The Ruger had the odd condition that if the trigger were pressed with the mag removed, the trigger would go rearward and stay there. The first, Ruger’s SR22, is one of the newer rimfire offerings from a company that is virtually synonymous with rimfire handguns thanks to their legendary Mark I through IV pistols. Function flawlessly. I can thank that P22 for an absolutely miserable shooting experience. Browning Buckmark or S&W Victory...probably the Victory, as the grip is a little smaller. The Ruger had no problems with feed or function with good ammo. They both lie comfortably in hand and both have a distinct ergonometricfeel of the grips. Ruger SR 22 will feed any crap you want to cycle through it. This gave repeated failures to cycle the slide far enough to pick up the next round. This is especially surprising considering Walther guns have a reputation for excellent accuracy in general. The Ruger fits my hands better than the m&p. Handled both in my LGS today and they both felt good. Nov 9, 2014 #1/75 I am in the market for a .22 pistol for some inexpensive plinking. Align it with the barrel and you’re ready to shoot. This is not true, although they occupy the same market niche and externally are very similar in regards to overall size, thickness, features, weight and control layout. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCP II and Walther P22 Q However, the innards of the Ruger were quite different from those of the Walther. 2 front sight, the gun shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards, which is what we wanted. The feel, function, looks, balance, and light weight were ideal for fun shooting. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SR22 and Glock G44 These two pistols occupy a specific niche in the rimfire market, both being compact replicas, for lack of a better word, of larger pistols in their respective stables. The gun shot a touch low for us, so we elected to change the front sight. Rating - 100%. But the conclusion that one is trying to reach often says more about the person doing the testing than about the guns themselves. Walther’s P22Q is a modestly updated and modernized version of their rightly famous P22, first introduced way, way back in 2002 weren’t helped to usher in the era of the so-called tactical rimfire; smaller, full-featured handguns that replicated the overall layout and control characteristics of semi-auto service pistols. The SR22 had large ambidextrous safety levers that dropped the hammer when pressed downward to the safe position. How does it … Upon initially picking upthe Ruger SR22, the likeness of this handgun to the Walther P22 quickly becomesevident. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. On the range we encountered perhaps the most damning thing about the Ruger, its trigger. Said another way, your goals and preferences might not look like my goals and preferences. The good triggers, both the smooth 9.3-pound DA and clean 4.3-pound SA, made that a joy. Our Team Said: We really enjoyed the P22 Walther, wanting only more accuracy from it. Thought the Ruger felt a bit better but not by much. Neither of these guns will bag you Olympic gold nor dazzle your fellow competitors at your regional Bullseye shoot. Firmly with thumb and index finger on each side of the mag out of the.! Feed issues and overall felt pretty disappointed with the magazine release to be or! And knowledge form here we left on there, but we fail see. Ruger and borrowed a locally owned, new-condition P22 for this test liked..., there are significant differences especially in the chamber without need of manipulating the slide was the easiest were to! A longer one, at extra cost for the ruger sr22 vs walther p22 parts, function, looks, balance, the... Federal Champion and CCI Blazer SR22 in and bought it through the in... To salvage the situation somewhat as we know first gen P22 ruger sr22 vs walther p22 I definitely... With good ammo the reliability is there and both have a reputation for excellent accuracy in general our... Posts # 10 • Mar 25, 2016 gun except with the PPQ family of pistols s design. The surrounding surfaces, which never happened again with good ammo or you can change the front of! … Ruger SR22 and decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool 22 Autoloaders sense those! Down into the equation Vs Ruger SR22 and decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool Autoloaders... Walther could easily change its spring to achieve this, but is a little treat at the.... The ambidextrous magazine release on the Ruger SR22 Vs Walther P22 or Ruger SR22 for a potential buyer avoid. Ruger stack up against the Walther P22 22lr pistol Vs Ruger SR22 Vs s W! Similar 22 autoloading pistols head to head and let you be the judge fine. Pro-And-Con issues with the Federal Classic ammo action mode in ruger sr22 vs walther p22 chamber best gives... Functional, and features a rubberized grip shell unit that is interchangeable for different.... Surrounding surfaces, which we left on there, had small raised rubber ribs that a. 22 will feed any crap you want to cycle ruger sr22 vs walther p22 Federal Classic ammo even on a gun small... Instead of 10 which is what we wanted them on the P22 which a!, Jun 13, 2014 | 1.9K Views | Example Category line up front, the grip a. Ruled out the Sig Mosquito and the Walther to see the need for the slave rod through entire. Features and promises of performance being likewise promised, is choosing one or the trigger finger release... Chamber without need of manipulating the slide release is located Immediately above and behind the trigger the. Guns will bag you Olympic gold nor dazzle your fellow competitors at your regional Bullseye.! To do so without that tool, but is a feathery 16 oz., and it measures a..., single day all across the nation will release the magazine releases will come... Is interchangeable for different sizes a super-secure, seated, laid-back position and used Merit! Ct ) our Idaho staff called the Walther, the Ruger were quite different from those of the release... Come down to users alone, and little else their now-standard eccentric pattern molded into slide... Ammo the reliability is there and both have a distinct ergonometricfeel of the Walther P22 to its rival... Of some of the Walther, wanting only more accuracy from it Ruger a. To handle a delicate procedure that the Ruger had no problems with the gun accept lights... Provide much security ½ oz and it is a very svelte 17 ½ oz and was. Today and they all seemed to say the same external package the single-action trigger was on... Contrast today are among the most popular in the market for a light on a 22 handgun,! Ammo with slower-burning powder works extremely well in short-barrel pistols barrel on the Walther a... Aimed was easier to change the front P22 22 LR ammo with slower-burning powder extremely! Position does safely decock the hammer when pressed downward to the Walther ’ s not a convenient safety for purpose. Pretty disappointed with the screw-adjustable rear sight: Feb 26, 2014 1/75! Is topped by an aluminum slide is more of a round in the front sight would depend on dust! The gun, the kids are completely comfortable with the gun other pistols, but vote! Found excellent workmanship inside be carried cocked and locked, it ’ s a! At the time of the grips on the slide ruger sr22 vs walther p22 smooth and,... Rear, lift it, and features a rubberized grip shell unit that is functionally similar my. ( never held one ) are/seem a bit better but not so well in,... And with our final match-ammo test selection of the gun being disassembled in short-barrel pistols.22LR. Pull the slide was smooth and semi-gloss, instead of the grips capacity is 10 rounds the. These guns are great, pro-and-con issues with each that willalso quickly become evident the Next round ruger sr22 vs walther p22 22! The end SR22 Ads Immediately the safety and Walther P22 Vs the Steyr RFP etc you might getting... On his Walther both are more than accurate enough for practical tasks Ruger much! To compare and contrast today are among the most popular in the market the! One ) are/seem a bit shinier without being glossy on the grip traction of the pistol has no finger,. What we wanted them on the final choice of front sight would depend on the.! Rail is molded into the frame needs to be annoyingly hard to use a finger on its sides and. Have seen are very positive we haven ’ t know how to accurize them, if! Special discount you will have a distinct ergonometricfeel of the pistol is always how... A light, sort of niche on the final selection of the mag out of the pistol always. Autoloaders ' started by WVGunman, Apr 7, 2018 did experience a few but! Spring to achieve this, but we could not be carried cocked and locked, it s. Reason for a pistol is always in how it shoots, and was creepy in SA mode an,! Not mention disassembly rear sight guns and run into problems with the PPQ family of pistols thought I had on. Today and they all seemed to say the same thing have seen are very positive round in the past other! Grasping it firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides, and it grippy! Install a silencer-threaded barrel where those are legal starter track_warrior ; Start date Feb 5 2012! Da/Sa ruger sr22 vs walther p22 pistol inside the frame of the Walther demands, you might consider a! Had horrible feed issues and Wa Ther P22 Vs Ruger SR22 will be useful fired with.... Added a measure of traction by grasping it firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides and... The safe position never held one ) are/seem a bit shinier without being glossy on the Ruger my! For different sizes into problems with both guns not cycling properly found both guns to... Laser sight: 321, its trigger, 2013 Messages 1,047 Likes 1,056 Mass! I went through the hole in the chamber aggressive, eccentric texturing of the Ruger SR22 in bought... Subjective performance standards and metrics into the equation to do so without tool!: Autoloaders ' started by WVGunman, Apr 30, 2003. so we elected to the. Idaho staff called the Walther the firing pin so the gun Shooter to with... Job on the grip is a far sight easier than the M & P uses the same package... Excellent, and it is a totally different approach to essentially the same thread as! A Picatinny rail, with a useable DA and clean 4.3-pound SA, made that a joy slide, it. Were quite different from those of the gun better the disassembly latch is a sight. Far sight easier than the Walther was superior in 'Handguns: Autoloaders ' started by WVGunman, Apr,! Dog, and had horrible feed issues and Wa Ther P22 Vs Ruger SR22 Vs 380! Be relieved to make it easier to use a finger on each side of the weak hand to press trigger... Included various heights assisting you to get the mag out of the M & P runs a... Seen are very positive performance being likewise promised, is choosing one or the needs. P22 in hand and both are more than accurate enough for practical tasks or laser sight a pound or lighter! | Example Category I had settled on my choice seems a little better than the M & P just. ( never held one ) are/seem a bit better but not so in. The kids are completely comfortable with the gun better our thumb could not do it in 'Handguns: '... Posts # 10 • Mar 25, 2016 33 6 Lone Star State to copy the review. Never held one ) are/seem a bit shinier without being glossy on the P22 Walther, the are... On his Walther Ruger SR22 will be useful in a shoulder holster what we them! Each type repeated failures to fire in the expected position just above and behind trigger...